The Label Printers Blog

How to Stop Overpaying for Custom Labels

Written by Lori Campbell | Jun 24, 2025

If you’ve ever wondered why the price of your labels fluctuates from one order to the next, or why two similar-looking labels can have vastly different costs, you’re not alone. Many businesses enter the custom label buying process with incomplete information — and that lack of clarity can lead to unnecessary spending. This guide is here to arm you with the knowledge you need to get the best label for your needs at a fair price, every time.

What Drives the Price of a Custom Label?

While every label order is unique, there are a handful of core factors that determine pricing. Understanding these will put you in the driver’s seat when sourcing labels.

Quantity and Order Frequency

Label manufacturing includes equipment setup processes (such as ink stations, printing plates, tooling and calibration) that are largely fixed, no matter how many labels you print. Ordering larger quantities at once reduces the impact of these fixed costs, lowering your per-label price.

Pro Tip: Consider placing fewer, larger orders per year or using a blanket order approach to stabilize pricing and availability.

Material Selection

From economy papers to high-performance films, the label material you choose can dramatically affect price. Your choice should align with your product’s use environment: indoor vs. outdoor, dry vs. moist, disposable vs. long-life. A reputable custom label manufacturer can help you avoid over-engineering while ensuring performance.

Adhesive Type

Adhesives range from general-purpose to highly specialized (e.g., freezer-grade, removable, ultra-permanent). Using a removable adhesive when permanence is required can lead to failure and reprints. Using a specialty adhesive when it’s not needed? That’s a waste of budget.

Added Design and Finishes

Metallic inks, embossing, foil stamping, and special varnishes all enhance aesthetics — and price. If your label is performing a luxury branding function, these costs may be justifiable. But if performance or clarity is more important than flash, you may be able to simplify and save.

Application Requirements

How and where the label is applied matters. Is it applied by hand or via automation? Will it need to conform to a curved surface? Do the labels need to be supplied on rolls, sheets, or fanfold? Share these details early to avoid surprises and ensure the most cost-effective solution.

Regulatory Requirements

If you operate in a regulated industry — such as food, electronics, or healthcare — your labels may require compliance with FDA, RoHS, FCC, or Prop 65 standards, among others. Make sure your label vendor knows your compliance requirements; non-compliance can be expensive!

Cost-Saving Moves Without Compromise

Bundle Your Needs

If you frequently order labels across multiple product lines or departments, combining these into fewer, larger print runs can significantly reduce unit cost. A smart custom label manufacturer will work with you to identify common specifications and streamline production.

Use Standard Sizes and Dies

Creating a new die for every label design gets expensive fast. Instead, consider standardizing your label shapes and sizes where possible. For example, aligning your shampoo and conditioner lines to use the same label die saves on tooling and setup.

Share Forecasts

The more your label partner understands your future needs, the better they can optimize production schedules, reserve materials, and potentially lower your costs. Think of it like meal-prepping with your manufacturer — more predictability means less waste and better pricing.

Test Before You Commit

Particularly when evaluating new or alternative materials, your label vendor should provide you with samples to test under your use conditions. Do they adhere properly to your packaging? Hold up under shipping and storage? A simple test could prevent a costly reprint.

Explore Substitutions

Tell your manufacturer your performance goals, then invite them to suggest alternate materials or constructions that might cost less but perform equally well.

Choosing a Label Manufacturer Who Saves You Money (and Stress)

Not all custom label manufacturers are created equal. A reliable partner will help you manage costs not just by quoting a low price, but by preventing errors and suggesting value-optimized solutions.

What to Look For:

Breadth of Capabilities: Can they handle both short runs and large volumes? Specialty materials and regulatory requirements?

Consultative Approach: Do they ask the right questions? Help with testing? Flag red flags before they become problems?

Flexibility: Can they offer inventory or distribution programs to help control your inventory costs and overstretched resources?

Support: Are they on top of regulatory changes? Can they provide the documentation you need for compliance reporting?

At The Label Printers, we’ve helped customers across industries reduce label costs by improving material selection, consolidating orders, and ensuring application success on the first try.

How to Identify Hidden Cost Drains in Your Custom Label Program

Rather than offering a worksheet here, let’s walk through how you can spot and reduce cost leaks in your label process. Use this checklist-style narrative to evaluate your program:

  • Ordering cadence: Are you placing orders monthly because that’s the habit? Check whether batching to quarterly orders could cut setup fees and stabilize pricing.
  • Run size: Does your order quantity typically fall just below a price break tier? You might be missing out on volume discounts by a small margin. Ask your manufacturer to model pricing at the next tier.
  • Material selection: Are you always defaulting to one substrate or adhesive? Materials evolve. Ask if a lower-cost option now meets your performance needs.
  • Design details: Strip away non-essential extras that don’t influence buying decisions.
  • Label shape or size: Custom sizes require custom tooling. Can you shift to stock to save cost and speed up delivery?
  • Application method: Misalignment between label format and your application process (manual vs. automated) can lead to errors, waste, or slowdowns. Confirm compatibility with your equipment.
  • Environmental exposure: Be sure you’re neither under- nor over-engineering for conditions like cold storage, humidity, or UV. A label that fails in-use costs more in returns and rework.
  • Spoilage trends: If spoilage or reorders are common, ask your label vendor to help investigate causes and possible solutions. Is the label hard to apply, causing mislabeled product that can’t be used? A mismatch with container material? Solving root causes cuts recurring costs.

Custom labels are too important to treat as an afterthought. With the right knowledge and the right partner, you can get labels that perform, impress, and save money in the process.